Verify message IDs during last message correction

Previously we did not check the ID in the replace tag against the ID of the last message from that JID because some MUC components change the message ID. In case the ID of the last message and the ID in the replace tag do not match, the message is simply treated as a normal message. Test-Information: Added unit tests to verify the new behavior and adjusted existing test cases for new behavior. Added test cases to ChatsManagerTest.cpp that test verification of replacement IDs for 1-to-1 chats and test non-verification of replacement IDs for MUC. All tests pass on OS X 10.11.6. Change-Id: I85b1d2138b056b445a663f3ee3ab89a56cef4a2a
author: Tobias Markmann <tm@ayena.de> 2016-09-19 09:35:57 (GMT)
committer: Tobias Markmann <tm@ayena.de> 2017-04-20 10:16:56 (GMT)
commit: c6daa0af52934c46ae3c26f9e9149d18e44c203e (patch)
tree: 28f11a1cc288932afe15ab0b9a4825af4506bdcf /Swift
parent: 57a611f942f2387e497334888a4bc4f68b9275c9 (diff)
download: swift-c6daa0af52934c46ae3c26f9e9149d18e44c203e.zip
swift-c6daa0af52934c46ae3c26f9e9149d18e44c203e.tar.bz2
7 files changed, 187 insertions, 19 deletions
diff --git a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.cpp b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.cpp
index 3e58e40..b6ca984 100644
--- a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.cpp
+++ b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.cpp
@@ -540,6 +540,20 @@ boost::optional<boost::posix_time::ptime> ChatController::getMessageTimestamp(st
     return message->getTimestamp();
 }
 
+void ChatController::addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) {
+    lastMessagesIDs_[from.toBare()] = {messageID, addMessage(message, senderDisplayNameFromMessage(from), senderIsSelf, label, avatarManager_->getAvatarPath(from), timeStamp)};
+}
+
+void ChatController::handleIncomingReplaceMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, const std::string& idToReplace, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) {
+    auto lastMessage = lastMessagesIDs_.find(from.toBare());
+    if ((lastMessage != lastMessagesIDs_.end()) && (lastMessage->second.idInStream == idToReplace)) {
+        replaceMessage(message, lastMessage->second.idInWindow, timeStamp);
+    }
+    else {
+        addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(from, message, messageID, senderIsSelf, label, timeStamp);
+    }
+}
+
 void ChatController::logMessage(const std::string& message, const JID& fromJID, const JID& toJID, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp, bool /* isIncoming */) {
     HistoryMessage::Type type;
     if (mucRegistry_->isMUC(fromJID.toBare()) || mucRegistry_->isMUC(toJID.toBare())) {
diff --git a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.h b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.h
index 1deb0bb..d5011e4 100644
--- a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.h
+++ b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.h
@@ -56,6 +56,8 @@ namespace Swift {
             virtual bool isIncomingMessageFromMe(std::shared_ptr<Message> message) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void postSendMessage(const std::string &body, std::shared_ptr<Stanza> sentStanza) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void preHandleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent> messageEvent) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
+            virtual void addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
+            virtual void handleIncomingReplaceMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, const std::string& idToReplace, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void postHandleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent> messageEvent, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& chatMessage) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void preSendMessageRequest(std::shared_ptr<Message>) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual std::string senderHighlightNameFromMessage(const JID& from) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
diff --git a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.cpp b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.cpp
index 7ae7dbd..0fc735a 100644
--- a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.cpp
+++ b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.cpp
@@ -276,18 +276,12 @@ void ChatControllerBase::handleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent> mes
 
         std::shared_ptr<Replace> replace = message->getPayload<Replace>();
         bool senderIsSelf = isIncomingMessageFromMe(message);
+        chatMessage = buildChatWindowChatMessage(body, senderHighlightNameFromMessage(from), senderIsSelf);
         if (replace) {
-            // Should check if the user has a previous message
-            std::map<JID, std::string>::iterator lastMessage;
-            lastMessage = lastMessagesUIID_.find(messageCorrectionJID(from));
-            if (lastMessage != lastMessagesUIID_.end()) {
-                chatMessage = buildChatWindowChatMessage(body, senderHighlightNameFromMessage(from), senderIsSelf);
-                replaceMessage(chatMessage, lastMessagesUIID_[messageCorrectionJID(from)], timeStamp);
-            }
+            handleIncomingReplaceMessage(from, chatMessage, message->getID(), replace->getID(), senderIsSelf, label, timeStamp);
         }
         else {
-            chatMessage = buildChatWindowChatMessage(body, senderHighlightNameFromMessage(from), senderIsSelf);
-            addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(from, chatMessage, senderIsSelf, label, timeStamp);
+            addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(from, chatMessage, message->getID(), senderIsSelf, label, timeStamp);
         }
 
         logMessage(body, from, selfJID_, timeStamp, true);
@@ -297,10 +291,6 @@ void ChatControllerBase::handleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent> mes
     postHandleIncomingMessage(messageEvent, chatMessage);
 }
 
-void ChatControllerBase::addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) {
-    lastMessagesUIID_[messageCorrectionJID(from)] = addMessage(message, senderDisplayNameFromMessage(from), senderIsSelf, label, avatarManager_->getAvatarPath(from), timeStamp);
-}
-
 std::string ChatControllerBase::getErrorMessage(std::shared_ptr<ErrorPayload> error) {
     std::string defaultMessage = QT_TRANSLATE_NOOP("", "Error sending message");
     if (!error->getText().empty()) {
diff --git a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.h b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.h
index d10df8f..88cb95c 100644
--- a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.h
+++ b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatControllerBase.h
@@ -48,6 +48,13 @@ namespace Swift {
 
     class ChatControllerBase : public boost::signals2::trackable {
         public:
+            class StreamWindowMessageIDPair {
+                public:
+                    std::string idInStream;
+                    std::string idInWindow;
+            };
+
+        public:
             virtual ~ChatControllerBase();
             void showChatWindow();
             void activateChatWindow();
@@ -82,7 +89,8 @@ namespace Swift {
             virtual std::string senderHighlightNameFromMessage(const JID& from) = 0;
             virtual bool isIncomingMessageFromMe(std::shared_ptr<Message>) = 0;
             virtual void preHandleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent>) {}
-            virtual void addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& time);
+            virtual void addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& time) = 0;
+            virtual void handleIncomingReplaceMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& chatMessage, const std::string& messageID, const std::string& idToReplace, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) = 0;
             virtual void postHandleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent>, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage&) {}
             virtual void preSendMessageRequest(std::shared_ptr<Message>) {}
             virtual bool isFromContact(const JID& from);
@@ -128,7 +136,7 @@ namespace Swift {
             ChatWindow* chatWindow_;
             JID toJID_;
             bool labelsEnabled_;
-            std::map<JID, std::string> lastMessagesUIID_;
+            std::map<JID, StreamWindowMessageIDPair> lastMessagesIDs_;
             PresenceOracle* presenceOracle_;
             AvatarManager* avatarManager_;
             bool useDelayForLatency_;
diff --git a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.cpp b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.cpp
index b685e04..fd3dc37 100644
--- a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.cpp
+++ b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.cpp
@@ -587,12 +587,22 @@ void MUCController::preHandleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent> messa
     }
 }
 
-void MUCController::addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& time) {
+void MUCController::addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& time) {
     if (from.isBare()) {
         chatWindow_->addSystemMessage(message, ChatWindow::DefaultDirection);
     }
     else {
-        ChatControllerBase::addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(from, message, senderIsSelf, label, time);
+        lastMessagesIDs_[from] = {messageID, addMessage(message, senderDisplayNameFromMessage(from), senderIsSelf, label, avatarManager_->getAvatarPath(from), time)};
+    }
+}
+
+void MUCController::handleIncomingReplaceMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, const std::string& /*idToReplace*/, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) {
+    auto lastMessage = lastMessagesIDs_.find(from);
+    if (lastMessage != lastMessagesIDs_.end()) {
+        replaceMessage(message, lastMessage->second.idInWindow, timeStamp);
+    }
+    else {
+        addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(from, message, messageID, senderIsSelf, label, timeStamp);
     }
 }
 
diff --git a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.h b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.h
index ba68ec6..b8f2aac 100644
--- a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.h
+++ b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/MUCController.h
@@ -81,7 +81,8 @@ namespace Swift {
             virtual std::string senderDisplayNameFromMessage(const JID& from) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual boost::optional<boost::posix_time::ptime> getMessageTimestamp(std::shared_ptr<Message> message) const SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void preHandleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent>) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
-            virtual void addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& time) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
+            virtual void addMessageHandleIncomingMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& time) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
+            virtual void handleIncomingReplaceMessage(const JID& from, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& message, const std::string& messageID, const std::string& idToReplace, bool senderIsSelf, std::shared_ptr<SecurityLabel> label, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void postHandleIncomingMessage(std::shared_ptr<MessageEvent>, const ChatWindow::ChatMessage& chatMessage) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void cancelReplaces() SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
             virtual void logMessage(const std::string& message, const JID& fromJID, const JID& toJID, const boost::posix_time::ptime& timeStamp, bool isIncoming) SWIFTEN_OVERRIDE;
diff --git a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/UnitTest/ChatsManagerTest.cpp b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/UnitTest/ChatsManagerTest.cpp
index 0356c6a..bf645d0 100644
--- a/Swift/Controllers/Chat/UnitTest/ChatsManagerTest.cpp
+++ b/Swift/Controllers/Chat/UnitTest/ChatsManagerTest.cpp
@@ -33,6 +33,7 @@
 #include <Swiften/FileTransfer/UnitTest/DummyFileTransferManager.h>
 #include <Swiften/Jingle/JingleSessionManager.h>
 #include <Swiften/MUC/MUCManager.h>
+#include <Swiften/Network/DummyTimerFactory.h>
 #include <Swiften/Presence/DirectedPresenceSender.h>
 #include <Swiften/Presence/PresenceOracle.h>
 #include <Swiften/Presence/StanzaChannelPresenceSender.h>
@@ -41,7 +42,6 @@
 #include <Swiften/VCards/VCardManager.h>
 #include <Swiften/VCards/VCardMemoryStorage.h>
 #include <Swiften/Whiteboard/WhiteboardSessionManager.h>
-#include <Swiften/Network/DummyTimerFactory.h>
 
 #include <Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatController.h>
 #include <Swift/Controllers/Chat/ChatsManager.h>
@@ -139,8 +139,11 @@ class ChatsManagerTest : public CppUnit::TestFixture {
 
 
     // Message correction tests
+    CPPUNIT_TEST(testChatControllerMessageCorrectionCorrectReplaceID);
+    CPPUNIT_TEST(testChatControllerMessageCorrectionIncorrectReplaceID);
     CPPUNIT_TEST(testChatControllerMessageCorrectionReplaceBySameResource);
     CPPUNIT_TEST(testChatControllerMessageCorrectionReplaceByOtherResource);
+    CPPUNIT_TEST(testMUCControllerMessageCorrectionNoIDMatchRequired);
 
     CPPUNIT_TEST_SUITE_END();
 
@@ -1309,6 +1312,73 @@ public:
         }
     }
 
+    /**
+     * This test case ensures correct handling of the ideal case where the replace
+     * message refers to a message with a known ID. This results in the last
+     * message being replaced.
+     */
+    void testChatControllerMessageCorrectionCorrectReplaceID() {
+        JID messageJID("testling@test.com/resource1");
+
+        MockChatWindow* window = new MockChatWindow();
+        mocks_->ExpectCall(chatWindowFactory_, ChatWindowFactory::createChatWindow).With(messageJID, uiEventStream_).Return(window);
+
+        auto message = std::make_shared<Message>();
+        message->setFrom(messageJID);
+        message->setTo(jid_);
+        message->setType(Message::Chat);
+        message->setBody("text before edit");
+        message->setID("someID");
+        manager_->handleIncomingMessage(message);
+
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text before edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastAddedMessage_));
+
+        message = std::make_shared<Message>();
+        message->setFrom(messageJID);
+        message->setTo(jid_);
+        message->setType(Message::Chat);
+        message->setBody("text after edit");
+        message->addPayload(std::make_shared<Replace>("someID"));
+        manager_->handleIncomingMessage(message);
+
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text before edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastAddedMessage_));
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text after edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastReplacedMessage_));
+    }
+
+    /**
+     * This test case ensures correct handling of the case where the replace
+     * message refers to a message with a unknown ID. The replace message should
+     * be treated like a non-repalce message in this case, with no replacement
+     * occuring.
+     */
+    void testChatControllerMessageCorrectionIncorrectReplaceID() {
+        JID messageJID("testling@test.com/resource1");
+
+        MockChatWindow* window = new MockChatWindow();
+        mocks_->ExpectCall(chatWindowFactory_, ChatWindowFactory::createChatWindow).With(messageJID, uiEventStream_).Return(window);
+
+        auto message = std::make_shared<Message>();
+        message->setFrom(messageJID);
+        message->setTo(jid_);
+        message->setType(Message::Chat);
+        message->setBody("text before edit");
+        message->setID("someID");
+        manager_->handleIncomingMessage(message);
+
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text before edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastAddedMessage_));
+
+        message = std::make_shared<Message>();
+        message->setFrom(messageJID);
+        message->setTo(jid_);
+        message->setType(Message::Chat);
+        message->setBody("text after failed edit");
+        message->addPayload(std::make_shared<Replace>("wrongID"));
+        manager_->handleIncomingMessage(message);
+
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text after failed edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastAddedMessage_));
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string(""), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastReplacedMessage_));
+    }
+
     void testChatControllerMessageCorrectionReplaceBySameResource() {
         JID messageJID("testling@test.com/resource1");
 
@@ -1320,6 +1390,7 @@ public:
         message->setTo(jid_);
         message->setType(Message::Chat);
         message->setBody("text before edit");
+        message->setID("someID");
         manager_->handleIncomingMessage(message);
 
         CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text before edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastAddedMessage_));
@@ -1346,6 +1417,7 @@ public:
         message->setTo(jid_);
         message->setType(Message::Chat);
         message->setBody("text before edit");
+        message->setID("someID");
         manager_->handleIncomingMessage(message);
 
         CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text before edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastAddedMessage_));
@@ -1361,6 +1433,77 @@ public:
         CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("text after edit"), MockChatWindow::bodyFromMessage(window->lastReplacedMessage_));
     }
 
+    void testMUCControllerMessageCorrectionNoIDMatchRequired() {
+        JID mucJID("SomeMUCRoom@test.com");
+        manager_->setOnline(true);
+
+        // Open chat window to a sender.
+        MockChatWindow* window = new MockChatWindow();
+
+        std::vector<JID> jids;
+        jids.emplace_back("foo@test.com");
+        jids.emplace_back("bar@test.com");
+
+        mocks_->ExpectCall(chatWindowFactory_, ChatWindowFactory::createChatWindow).With(mucJID, uiEventStream_).Return(window);
+
+        auto nickname = std::string("SomeNickName");
+        // Join room
+        {
+            auto joinRoomEvent = std::make_shared<JoinMUCUIEvent>(mucJID, boost::optional<std::string>(), nickname);
+            uiEventStream_->send(joinRoomEvent);
+        }
+
+        auto genRemoteMUCPresence = [=]() {
+            auto presence = Presence::create();
+            presence->setFrom(mucJID.withResource(nickname));
+            presence->setTo(jid_);
+            return presence;
+        };
+
+        {
+            auto presence = genRemoteMUCPresence();
+            auto userPayload = std::make_shared<MUCUserPayload>();
+            userPayload->addStatusCode(110);
+            userPayload->addItem(MUCItem(MUCOccupant::Owner, jid_, MUCOccupant::Moderator));
+            presence->addPayload(userPayload);
+            stanzaChannel_->onPresenceReceived(presence);
+        }
+
+        {
+            auto presence = genRemoteMUCPresence();
+            presence->setFrom(mucJID.withResource("someDifferentNickname"));
+            auto userPayload = std::make_shared<MUCUserPayload>();
+            userPayload->addItem(MUCItem(MUCOccupant::Member, JID("foo@bar.com"), MUCOccupant::Moderator));
+            presence->addPayload(userPayload);
+            stanzaChannel_->onPresenceReceived(presence);
+        }
+
+        {
+            Message::ref mucMirrored = std::make_shared<Message>();
+            mucMirrored->setFrom(mucJID.withResource(nickname));
+            mucMirrored->setTo(jid_);
+            mucMirrored->setType(Message::Groupchat);
+            mucMirrored->setID("fooBlaID_1");
+            mucMirrored->setBody("Some misssssspelled message.");
+            manager_->handleIncomingMessage(mucMirrored);
+        }
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("Some misssssspelled message."), window->bodyFromMessage(window->lastAddedMessage_));
+
+        // Replace message with non-matching ID
+        {
+            Message::ref mucMirrored = std::make_shared<Message>();
+            mucMirrored->setFrom(mucJID.withResource(nickname));
+            mucMirrored->setTo(jid_);
+            mucMirrored->setType(Message::Groupchat);
+            mucMirrored->setID("fooBlaID_3");
+            mucMirrored->setBody("Some correctly spelled message.");
+            mucMirrored->addPayload(std::make_shared<Replace>("fooBlaID_2"));
+            manager_->handleIncomingMessage(mucMirrored);
+        }
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(std::string("Some correctly spelled message."), window->bodyFromMessage(window->lastReplacedMessage_));
+    }
+
+
 private:
     std::shared_ptr<Message> makeDeliveryReceiptTestMessage(const JID& from, const std::string& id) {
         std::shared_ptr<Message> message = std::make_shared<Message>();
author	Tobias Markmann <tm@ayena.de>	2016-09-19 09:35:57 (GMT)
committer	Tobias Markmann <tm@ayena.de>	2017-04-20 10:16:56 (GMT)
commit	c6daa0af52934c46ae3c26f9e9149d18e44c203e (patch)
tree	28f11a1cc288932afe15ab0b9a4825af4506bdcf /Swift
parent	57a611f942f2387e497334888a4bc4f68b9275c9 (diff)
download	swift-c6daa0af52934c46ae3c26f9e9149d18e44c203e.zip swift-c6daa0af52934c46ae3c26f9e9149d18e44c203e.tar.bz2